
Seventeen workers died on 9 November when an overhead crane dropped into an electric arc furnace at the HABAŞ steelworks in Aliağa, İzmir province, western Turkey. The fall set off an explosion and a fire. The death toll is the figure given by İzmir governor Süleyman Elban; reports of the number injured range from 12 to 14. Some media later put the number of dead at 19; at the time of publication we could not find an official source for that.
What is known
The governor's first account was that the crane came off and went into the furnace while liquid steel was being poured; he also referred to the work as a boiler replacement. Energy Minister Alparslan Bayraktar spoke of the crane coming down during routine furnace work. A plant worker told AFP that a crane rope had broken. No official body has confirmed this.
The investigation was ordered by Turkey's president. Nine people are in pre-trial detention by court order, and two more – the company chairman among them – are confined to their homes. The cause has not yet been officially determined.
How molten metal cranes are built
A crane that moves ladles of molten metal is held to stricter rules than an ordinary overhead crane (see our guide to overhead and gantry cranes). Under EN 14492-2, the European standard for hoists, the failure of any one part between motor and drum must not let the load drop. Designers usually meet this in one of two ways:
- a doubled hoist – two motors, two gearboxes and two brakes, with either brake strong enough to hold the ladle by itself;
- a safety brake acting directly on the rope drum, together with doubled reeving, so that a broken shaft or gearbox still leaves the drum locked.
In the heaviest ladle cranes described by manufacturers, the ladle hangs on several separate rope systems, each hoist has two working brakes plus one on the drum, and a damper on the equaliser beam stops the ladle lurching if a rope parts.
Next to a furnace, these cranes work long hours in great heat and fall into the highest duty groups, which is why their ropes and brakes are checked more often than those of cranes in an ordinary workshop.
We will update this report when official findings are published.
Source: Turkish Minute